A Malaska Golf Member has a great question about "feel and real."
Mike talks about his mentor Joe Nichols who taught him how to compress the golf ball and gain speed instead of dragging the handle out in front.
The original question is about when you make practice swings and the club circles around your hands. Does this concept depart from what Joe taught? Mike says no.
Joe wanted you to tip the club out because he wanted your hips to stay back as you brought the handle down. When you swing at full speed, the club will land in a perfect position for you to hit the ball.
If you don't tip the club out on the downswing, the club's momentum will drop the club and then push your hands away from you. You'll have to twist your hands to get the clubface square with the ball. This means everything is late.
The key is to keep the club from getting too far behind you. That is why "tipping the club out" gets you in the perfect position to hit the ball.
The club is still circling your hands when you are "tipping the club out”, it's the same thing. It is a feeling of a change of direction and not a reality.